Blog

Google Facing A £7 Billion Class Action Lawsuit

On November 25, 2024, the UK’s Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) authorized a £7 billion class action lawsuit against Google, alleging the company abused its dominance in the search market. The lawsuit, initiated by consumer advocate Nikki Stopford in September 2023, claims Google’s practices led to higher advertising costs, which were subsequently passed on to consumers. Specific allegations include compelling Android phone manufacturers to pre-install Google Search and Chrome, and paying Apple to make Google the default search engine on Safari. Google disputes these claims, asserting that users choose its services due to their utility.

This case marks another significant legal challenge for Google, which is already embroiled in a high-profile antitrust trial in the United States. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has accused the company of monopolistic behavior, focusing on similar practices around search engine dominance and exclusive deals. Together, these lawsuits intensify scrutiny on Google’s business practices globally, raising questions about the future of competition in the tech industry.

How To NOT Recover From An Algorithm Update

Over the last 4 years Google has implemented sweeping changes to its ranking systems in a series of algorithm updates. Each update has marked a significant change in the types of websites Google targets as well as changes to the way information is presented within the search results. Both of which have had significant impact both positive and negative on many websites across the internet. 

For those that have seen ranking declines the impact can be devastating. Some will notice an immediate drop off in organic traffic and rankings. While others will notice a gradual decline over time. Either way if a website was significantly dependent on organic traffic before the update, these types of declines can have an overwhelming negative impact on the marketing and business objectives going forward.

Many smart SEOs claim to understand the correct strategies to reverse these negative trends, and most of them are right. However very few SEOs are willing to tell you what needs to be done in order to never recover. If you wanted to continue your websites downward spiral, what steps would you take? It might seem ridiculous and counterproductive to even focus on continuing negative trends, however I’ve noticed for most businesses they are unable to do what needs to be done until they understand their own negative behavior completely.

Here are five negative behaviors that are holding back your website from recovering after a negative algorithm update. 

Do Nothing

In the last several years I’ve seen a lot of people outside of the SEO community complain about these algorithm updates. Many have been hit by the Helpful Content Update. In each instance I will reach out to them and ask what have you done to fix the problem. In almost every example I found of a website owner complaining publicly, none of them have done anything to fix the situation they’re in. It seems as if the only thing they think will help them is complaining to Google or the rest of the world of the dire situation that they are in. I can promise you as an SEO that’s been doing this for over 15 years that complaining to Google and others will never fix your SEO problems. You have to take decisive action to fix the problem that you’re in. On the rare occasion that someone from Google will pay attention to your complaints, they are 10 times more likely to help you if you can demonstrate that you’re already trying on your end to fix the problem.

Ignore Experts

Generally speaking there are three types of SEOs: SEOs that only participate in online discussions may have interesting things to say and sometimes can provide different perspectives worth considering, however they lack the real world experience to provide value and quality guidance. The SEOs that ignore the online community entirely may have tons of experience however lack the context of a broader professional community that can provide different ideas and perspectives that they had considered before. And, finally those that participate in both real world experience along with the vibrant conversations in the community. 

Can you guess which of these three are borderline obsessed and passionate about algorithm updates? Some of us eat, breath, and sleep SEO. So much so that I can list more than five in our industry that I think might have legitimate mental health problems as it’s related to their obsession with SEO. Which is why I’m always flabbergasted when I see site owners that are experiencing real dramatic damage to their traffic and marketing efforts because of a search engine algorithm update, completely ignore the experts that are telling them what to do. Many of the SEOs that you speak to will have all of the answers you need if you are willing to listen and believe in what they’re saying. We provide this guidance based on experience working with other websites and helping them recover. We are not doing “guess work” everything is quantifiable and we can show examples of our work. Which is why I just don’t understand why so many people ignore SEOs. 

Make No Changes

Some website owners impacted by negative algorithm updates DO listen to the experts. In fact, occasionally they hire us to help them fix their problems. Typically for me this means doing an exhaustive SEO audit that focuses on the types of technical SEO and content that are most likely related to the update impacting their site. My SEO audits are extremely detailed and exhaustive. For each recommendation I provide not only an explanation of what went wrong but also detailed steps on how to resolve the issue, oftentimes including code that a company’s developers can simply copy and paste to implement the required changes that I’m recommending. After the audit is completed I make sure that everyone understands the entire document fully and I do everything I can to position the client in a way to best possibly implement my recommendations. 

Which is why it’s so frustrating when many clients fail to implement the recommendations I’m making. In some instances they will implement several of the high priority items and ignore the rest. In other instances they ignore the audit completely and carry on without making any substantial changes at all. For each website owner the reasons behind this inaction may be different but the results are always the same: Continued failure within the search results. Oftentimes a lack of budget or resources is cited as a reason not to implement specific changes. This is due in large part because the websites profitability has declined since the algorithm update occurred. However these changes are meant to increase your websites organic ROI if implemented quickly, therefore the expense required to implement the SEO audit will pay for itself and more after an update rebound occurs. I think many website owners are also surprised to find such dramatic recommendations made. In some instances I’ve heard of websites rebounding from the Helpful Content Update after deleting 90% of their content. That might seem like an extreme scenario however if the website has lost 60% or 70% of its total traffic extreme measures may be needed. 

No matter the reasoning continuing the status quo will almost guarantee no recovery going forward. If you’re concerned about cost I encourage you to do an opportunity cost analysis on doing nothing. It always shows continued loss in traffic, rankings, and revenue. 

Blame Someone Else

I cannot tell you how many times I’ve spoken to clients who have experienced an algorithm update decline, or a manual penalty and instead of taking responsibility for the situation they’re in, they point the finger at someone else. I’ve spoken to clients who have received manual link penalties and swear that they are the victim of their competitors sabotaging their SEO efforts with toxic backlinks. Or that the repetitive content template stuffed with keywords on hundreds of pages, was placed on their website by a former SEO they didn’t know about. At the end of the day none of this matters. To fix the problem you need to take ownership over it and do what needs to be done to resolve the issue. In situations like manual penalties it’s always easier to get them revoked if you admit to your wrongdoings in your reconsideration request. Failure to exhibit an act of contrition (sorry I was raised catholic) will result in complete apathy and lack of sympathy from search quality engineers that always have more data than you do. To fix your problems you have to own them and take responsibility. 

Listen To Google

Despite there being many talented SEO consultants that can help you recover from an algorithm update, many website owners wrongfully assume the best advice for their situation will come directly from Google itself. While it is true that representatives from Google may understand the inner workings of their search engine much more than SEO consultants, their input to your problems are likely not to provide real benefit. Probably the most common reason for this is that each algorithm update and ranking system judges every domain individually within the context of the website’s content, technical infrastructure, and backlinks. Which means that any strategy developed to recover from a negative decline in rankings needs to be customized specifically with your website’s data in mind. Representatives from search engines rarely if ever make statements that fit a specific and targeted context that is required to meet the needs of your individual situation. Instead the majority of statements and advice that come from Google representatives are meant to be applied in a general sense without an understanding of any unique issues that your site may be experiencing.

Another common misunderstanding of statements from Google representatives is their difference in perspective. A search engine representative will be an expert on their systems alone; this is not the same as being an SEO expert. Search engine representatives can talk in detail about how their ranking systems work and how your site may have been negatively impacted as a result. However they do not have the same experience in responding to these systems from the outside. This is a substantial difference in perspective that is often confused and misunderstood by website owners that take search engine representatives’ statements and recommendations verbatim. Instead you should partner with SEO experts that understand how to work with these ranking systems from the outside in order to achieve better results. A search engine representative will not have that same level of expertise.

If you’ve been impacted negatively by an algorithm update or system change and you are committed to doing what is required to reverse the negative decline in traffic and rankings you should contact me today. I will start with an honest discussion with you about your recovery chances before we agree to a consulting engagement. If you decide to move forward with working with me, I’ll develop a custom audit and strategy focused on recovering from your decline. I’ll review the entire thing with you and your complete team and provide any available resources for additional learning and understanding. Through the entire process, until your recovery is seen, I’ll hold your hand and answer any questions that you might have. Because the only thing that makes all the frustration I’ve described in this article worth it, is seeing my clients succeed and regain traffic, rankings, and lost revenue. Together we can make it happen!

OpenAI’s SearchGPT Set to Challenge Google’s Search Dominance by End of 2024

Google Updates Search Quality Rater Guidelines

OpenAI is set to launch its new AI-powered search engine, SearchGPT, by the end of 2024. Announced by OpenAI’s head of media, Varun Shetty, SearchGPT will compete with Google by delivering natural-language answers to user queries, providing sources for the information. Currently in testing, its initial performance reviews suggest that improvements are still needed. This move signals a potential shift in the search engine landscape, where OpenAI’s innovative technology could challenge Google’s long-standing dominance in web search.

To compete with rising AI-based search tools, Google has been integrating AI Overviews into its search results. This feature, part of Google’s Search Generative Experience (SGE), offers summarized, AI-generated answers directly in the results page. By synthesizing information from multiple sources, AI Overviews provide quick, comprehensive responses, reducing the need for users to click through multiple links. This initiative aims to keep Google at the forefront of search by blending traditional search methods with the growing demand for AI-enhanced experiences.

As OpenAI’s SearchGPT prepares to enter the market and Google continues to refine AI Overviews, the future of search is poised for a major transformation. Both companies are leveraging advanced AI to deliver more intuitive, conversational search experiences, but questions remain about how users will respond and what impact these changes will have on the broader search ecosystem. While the competition promises innovation, it also introduces uncertainty, as the balance between AI convenience and information accuracy will be critical in shaping the next era of web search.

Google is Testing Verified Search Results For Brands

Reuters is reporting that on October 4, 2024, Google began testing a new feature that adds verified check marks next to certain businesses in its search results. The goal of this initiative is to help users identify legitimate companies and avoid fake websites that could present misleading information. The feature, currently visible to a limited number of users, highlights verified businesses such as Apple and Meta. This experiment aims to enhance user trust in search results, following a trend of increasing concerns around online fraud and misinformation.

“We regularly experiment with features that help shoppers identify trustworthy businesses online, and we are currently running a small experiment showing checkmarks next to certain businesses on Google,” – Google public affairs via The Verge.

When a user hovers over the checkmark a tooltip like display reads, “Google’s signals suggest that this business is the business that it says it is,”.

To learn more about how this change may impact your search results or your business, contact Joe today!

Google Introduces AI-Powered Voice Search and Enhanced Image Queries

In a new wave of updates aimed at revolutionizing its search engine, Google has integrated advanced artificial intelligence (AI) features that allow users to interact with visual content using voice commands. Announced in early October 2024, the latest AI injection enables users to ask questions about images or videos they encounter, with responses generated through AI summaries. This marks a continuation of Google’s efforts to enhance its search capabilities with AI, following the introduction of “AI Overviews” earlier in 2023.

One of the key advancements includes the ability for users to query visual content in a conversational manner. Through Google Lens, users can now ask questions about objects in real-time via their camera or even ask about moving subjects in video clips—such as fish swimming in an aquarium. This feature is available to users testing the system in Google Labs.

These updates reflect Google’s broader goal of making search more intuitive and accessible. Rajan Patel, Google’s vice president of search engineering, noted that the company’s objective is to make search “simpler and more effortless,” allowing users to search in various ways—whether through text, voice, or visuals.

However, the implementation of AI has not been without issues. In previous updates, Google’s AI-driven summaries occasionally produced misleading or incorrect information, which raised concerns about the accuracy of search results. To address this, Google is introducing more external links within AI summaries to improve transparency and reliability, especially after past incidents where its AI suggested erroneous advice like putting glue on pizza.

This latest phase of Google’s AI evolution underscores the company’s commitment to staying competitive against emerging “answer engines” such as ChatGPT and Perplexity, which are attracting attention for their conversational AI search models?.

Read more: